Dear Mr. Miller,
I first started reading comic books in late 1984. I believe
Green Lantern was the first comic I collected. Little did I know that I was picking up the hobby just before it was about to enter a glory period like it had never seen before.
For the past several years, superhero comics had begun their next big step forward, the first since the Marvel Revolution of the Sixties. Your work on
Daredevil and Alan Moore's work on various titles were introducing a new level of sophistication to the genre.
In 1986, it all came to a head. After the conclusion of
Crisis on Infinite Earths, DC Comics had a clean slate to reintroduce and restart their books for a new audience. Your two great Batman books came out that year,
The Dark Knight Returns and
Batman: Year One.
It is impossible to overstate how much you blew my young mind. Those books, and others that followed in the year ahead, moved my literacy level up several notches and introduced me to ideas and themes I hadn't read yet in anything intended for my age group. This was mostly because the books I'm talking about weren't really intended for my age group. I remember seeing naked people in
Watchmen and hoping my mom would never think to thumb through it herself.
I will always be a great admirer of yours because of those books, along with many that followed, including:
Sin City,
Give Me Liberty, and others.
Because of this, my ever undying admiration of you, I'm asking you to please stop a moment and take a look at your recent work. Especially the work you've done featuring your favorite character, Batman.
I read
The Dark Knight Strikes Again and defended it through the first issue, when people went through shock because of how different it looked than your predecessor. I stuck with you through the second issue. Then came the third and I could defend you no longer. Batman so over the top I expect froth to be coming out of his mouth. Batman grinning in triumph as Lex Luthor's brains are smashed out of his skull. Batman supposedly fighting for the freedom of the little guy, then turning around and supporting the idea of Superman running the show. Oh, I guess it was okay for us to have a dictator, he just needed to be a nice one.
And let's talk about Superman. First, he's a pawn of the government in
The Dark Knight Returns. Sure, it's a betrayal of the character's origins (though it's a betrayal that everyone else seems to base their opinion of the character on), but it worked in the story and you've even voiced regret that he was marginalized that way.
So, when you have a chance to put him into your next opus, you give him a reason why he was a government pawn and it's a convincing one. By the end of the story, however, he's decided that he's not really one of us and that the Earth is really his. Again, you swap one dictator for another.
The real problem, though, is what you've done to the character you helped define for the modern age. I'm, of course, talking about Batman. So, in
The Dark Knight Strikes Again he's become a sadist. He's also so over the top and unreasonable that he really isn't much of a hero anymore. Even that couldn't prepare me for
All Star Batman and Robin.
All Star Batman and Robin has gotten a lot of press. To comic book fans, it was engineered as the perfect Batman book. You are writing it and Jim Lee's drawing it. Even I was floored at the prospect. It's too bad that the book is horrible.
I can't blame this on Jim Lee. His art still works. I blame it on your script. The first issue is half filled with womens' asses hanging out of panties. This happens all the time in comics by the way, but only to this extent typically in bad ones. Then in issue two, you have Batman cooking police, corrupt or not, with the Batmobile's flamethrower. The worst part, though, is the way he treats Robin. I get what you were going for with this, but when Dick Grayson acts scared and Batman backhands him (Dick's parents were killed about 30 minutes before this in front of him), you are officially not on this character's side anymore.
But the worst of it was the line. The line that is just starting to live in infamy. Dick asks Batman who he is and Batman yells at him, "What are you, retarded? I'm the goddam Batman!"
Since when did Marv from Sin City put on a costume and start driving around Gotham?
You are, or were, better than this. I can't tell you what to create or what your takes on characters should be but as of now, I'm out. Your current is selling on the strength of what it used to be, not what it is. I have faith that in the future, you'll produce something new that stuns me again (in a good way). I'm not banking on
Batman: Holy Terror to do it.
Regards,
Dan Trudeau